In negotiations, our previous discussions emphasized the significance of “who speaks first.” However, recent groundbreaking research in negotiation science has shed light on a new aspect: the divergent impact of pre-negotiation “small talk” on men and women negotiators.

Brooke A. Shaughnessy, Alexandra A. Mislin, and Tanja Hentschel, esteemed researchers in this field, delve into their study, “Should He Chitchat? The Benefits of Small Talk for Male Versus Female Negotiators,” published in the prestigious journal Basic and Applied Social Psychology. Their findings unravel the profound influence of small talk on perceptions and outcomes in negotiation scenarios.

Remarkable Findings

Often dismissed as trivial or inconsequential, small talk has long been recognized as a social lubricant that eases tension, builds rapport, and establishes a foundation for fruitful conversations. However, its impact on negotiations, particularly regarding gender dynamics, has remained relatively unexplored until now.

The researchers embarked on a comprehensive examination of the role of small talk in negotiations, explicitly focusing on salary negotiations as a critical domain where differences in outcomes can have far-reaching consequences. Their objective was to determine whether engaging in pre-negotiation small talk benefits both men and women negotiators equally or if gender disparities come into play.

Analyzing data from extensive surveys and simulations involving real-life negotiation scenarios, Shaughnessy, Mislin, and Hentschel uncovered fascinating insights into the impact of small talk on negotiation outcomes. Contrary to popular belief, their research revealed an apparent disparity in the advantages experienced by men and women when engaging in pre-negotiation small talk.

The researchers found that men who engaged in small talk before negotiations experienced a significant boost in positive negotiation outcomes. Moreover, even the slightest gesture of engaging in casual conversation contributed to securing better deals for men. Conversely, women negotiators did not enjoy the same benefits from pre-negotiation small talk.

The Role OF Gender Expectations and Stereotypes

The researchers conducted further analysis to understand the underlying reasons behind this favorable perception of men and the lack thereof for women. They discovered that gender expectations and stereotypes are pivotal in shaping these dynamics. For example, women are generally expected to be more communicative, including making more small talk, as part of their societal role. However, this expectation works against them in negotiations. Engaging in pre-negotiation small talk does not generate the same social capital for women as it does for men. It can be perceived as conforming to expected gender norms, potentially diminishing their perceived assertiveness and negotiation prowess.

On the other hand, men are not subject to the same communicative expectations. When they engage in pre-negotiation “chit chat,” it is seen as an unexpected behavior that goes beyond their stereotypical roles. This unexpectedness creates a positive impression and enhances their negotiation outcomes. The researchers concluded that these divergent reactions to identical behaviors highlight the influence of gender expectations and the importance of challenging and breaking free from traditional gender stereotypes.

The findings of this study have profound implications for individuals navigating the complex world of negotiations, particularly in the context of gender biases. In the evolving landscape of Economy 2.0, where diversity, inclusivity, and equality are at the forefront of discussions, it is crucial to recognize the influence of implicit biases and stereotypes that can shape negotiations.

The Role Of Small Talk In Sales Conversations

For female sales professionals, the study underscores the importance of engaging in pre-negotiation small talk, as it is an expectation imposed by gender norms. Failing to do so may lead to negative perceptions and potentially hinder their negotiation outcomes. However, women negotiators need to be aware that engaging in small talk may not yield the same additional benefits enjoyed by their male counterparts. While it is disheartening to observe the disparity in outcomes for women negotiators, it is essential to recognize the underlying biases and work towards addressing them. One key aspect is challenging the gender expectations and stereotypes perpetuating these biases. Women should be encouraged to assert themselves confidently in negotiations, breaking free from the notion that excessive small talk is necessary to conform to societal expectations.

Conversely, male sales professionals can leverage the advantages that small talk offers. However, they must exercise caution to ensure their small talk is authentic and genuine. Any hint of manipulation or insincerity can quickly undermine their efforts and erode the social capital from engaging in pre-negotiation conversations. On the other hand, real connections built through small talk can foster trust and rapport, paving the way for mutually beneficial negotiation outcomes.

The implications of this research extend beyond individual negotiations. It highlights the need for organizations to cultivate inclusive and equitable environments where gender biases are actively challenged and dismantled. By promoting awareness of the differential impact of small talk and encouraging open dialogue about gender expectations, companies can foster an atmosphere that supports the professional growth and success of all employees, regardless of gender.

Moreover, the findings of this study underscore the significance of continuous learning and adapting to the ever-evolving landscape of negotiations. In Economy 2.0, where customization, personalization, and understanding individual differences are paramount, a one-size-fits-all approach is no longer practical. Instead, sales professionals must equip themselves with a diverse skill set that encompasses not only product knowledge and negotiation tactics but also a deep understanding of the complexities of human interactions and the influence of gender dynamics.

To succeed in negotiations, sales professionals must develop a keen awareness of the nuances. This includes understanding the biases and stereotypes associated with gender, recognizing the potential advantages and disadvantages they may face, and adapting their approach accordingly. By leveraging the power of effective communication, empathy, and authenticity, sales professionals can navigate negotiations more effectively and create win-win outcomes for all parties involved.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the groundbreaking research conducted by Shaughnessy, Mislin, and Hentschel sheds light on the differential impact of pre-negotiation small talk on men and women negotiators. The study reveals the existence of gender biases and expectations that influence the perception and outcomes of negotiations. While women negotiators are expected to engage in small talk, they may receive different benefits than their male counterparts. However, this research serves as a call to action to challenge these biases, create more equitable environments, and equip sales professionals with the knowledge and skills to navigate negotiations successfully. By recognizing the power of communication and understanding the complexities of gender dynamics, we can strive towards more inclusive and effective negotiation practices in Economy 2.0.

When you think about sales effectiveness at your organization, does it seem like you are close but just missing those unique elements that give you that competitive edge? Looking for a way to understand how your buyer thinks, decides, and reveals information? At The Nova Consulting Group, we believe that professional selling is a craft. With the Advanced Sales Conversation©, you have those missing elements that move your salespeople from competency to mastery. With our deep understanding of what makes and sustains high-performance organizations, we provide integrated solutions that do not replace your sales methodology and yet advance a progressive selling mindset. Be bolder, more insightful, and get results. To learn more about how to master the craft of sales and encourage sustainable high performance, call  (617) 933-7249 or email info@novaconsultinggrp.com.